Fraudulent San Jose Psychic Gets 5 Years In Prison

San Jose, CA- A psychic named Shirley Stanley conned a senior citizen in a scam commonly known as the “Sweetheart Scam.” The 48-year-old con artist stole nearly all of the victim’s life savings.

She also scammed another unsuspecting woman out of a large sum of money. She accomplished both of these scams through lies and deceit. Stanley has been arrested and was sentenced to five years in prison.

Santa Clara County Superior Court ruled Friday that Stanley was guilty of the charges filed against her. She was also found guilty of contracting without a license.

The court also served justice by sentencing her 43-year-old husband Costello for knowingly selling defective concrete patios. He received one year in county jail followed by three years probation.

It all started in 2007 when Stanley met a senior male at a San Jose Post Office. According to the District Attorney’s Office, the scammer moved quickly to befriend him. Shortly after meeting, Stanley pretended to be in love with the man, and the two got engaged.

Unfortunately, she was conning him out of his money the whole time. The total amount stolen added up to at least $236,0000.

The con artist got this money from the victim by telling him that her two kids needed costly operations. This was a blatant lie because her children were perfectly healthy.

The victim gave her the $236,000 believing that it would save her kids’ lives. Prosecutors seized the money from her bank account and gave it back to him once her crimes were exposed.

Stanley also conned a different woman from San Jose into giving her $100,000 along with expensive liquor. She told the victim that she could exorcise her dead boyfriends’ “evil spirit.”

Stanley and Costello lied to the woman by telling her that they would use the money to cure her current boyfriend’s drinking problem by donating it to a church.

Only $43,000 of the woman’s retirement money has been returned to her so far since the couple’s arrest. The court has ordered them to pay the rest at a later time.

In 2008, Costello pretended to be a licensed contractor so that he could steal $15,600 from two victims. He sold concrete that he knew was defective to these two individuals. They have since gotten reimbursed.

The arrests happened last summer thanks to the brother of the “sweetheart scam” victim. He came forward to the police to report the suspicious activity after hearing about it from her brother.

I’m so glad that the police have been able to bring another scam artist to justice! Scams like these prove that fake Psychics use mumbo jumbo like “evil spirits” and “curses” to separate you from your money. Please see my reviews page for a list of authentic psychics who would never prey on you like this!

Customer Favorite Online Psychics For 2023
psychic source logo
Psychic Source
#1 Rated!
Readings as low as $10!
path forward psychics logo
Path Forward
Great Deal!
Readings as low as $5!
psychic access logo
Psychic Access
Owned by Psychics!
Get 6 minutes free!


Angela Moore founded Psychic Review Online in 2008 after being scammed out of her life savings by a psychic con artist. Since then she has devoted her time to rooting out the frauds and helping people find a real psychic reader.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply

      Psychic Review Online